X

The Taming of Evolution

The Persistence of Nonevolutionary Views in the Study of Humans

Davydd Greenwood

The theory of evolution has clearly altered our views of the biological world, but in the study of human beings, evolutionary and preevolutionary views continue to coexist in a state of perpetual tension. The Taming of Evolution addresses the questions of how and why this is so. Davydd Greenwood offers a sustained critique of the nature/nurture debate, revealing the complexity of the relationship between science and ideology. He maintains that popular contemporary theories, most notably E. O. Wilson’s human sociobiology and Marvin Harris’s cultural materialism, represent pre-Darwinian notions overlaid by elaborate evolutionary terminology. Greenwood first details the humoral-environmental and Great Chain of Being theories that dominated Western thinking before Darwin. He systematically compares these ideas with those later influenced by Darwin’s theories, illuminating the surprising continuities between them. Greenwood suggests that it would be neither difficult nor socially dangerous to develop a genuinely evolutionary understanding of human beings, so long as we realized that we could not derive political and moral standards from the study of biological processes.

Publisher: Cornell University Press
Subject: Anthropology
Print ISBN: 9781501719882
eBook ISBN: 9781501719882

DESCRIPTION

The theory of evolution has clearly altered our views of the biological world, but in the study of human beings, evolutionary and preevolutionary views continue to coexist in a state of perpetual tension. The Taming of Evolution addresses the questions of how and why this is so. Davydd Greenwood offers a sustained critique of the nature/nurture debate, revealing the complexity of the relationship between science and ideology. He maintains that popular contemporary theories, most notably E. O. Wilson’s human sociobiology and Marvin Harris’s cultural materialism, represent pre-Darwinian notions overlaid by elaborate evolutionary terminology. Greenwood first details the humoral-environmental and Great Chain of Being theories that dominated Western thinking before Darwin. He systematically compares these ideas with those later influenced by Darwin’s theories, illuminating the surprising continuities between them. Greenwood suggests that it would be neither difficult nor socially dangerous to develop a genuinely evolutionary understanding of human beings, so long as we realized that we could not derive political and moral standards from the study of biological processes.

RELATED TITLES

Somali-English and English-Somali dictionary

DETAILS

Browse All Cornell University Press Books

The history of Dutchess County, New York

DETAILS

Browse All Cornell University Press Books

Things mother used to make : a collection of old time recipes, some nearly one hundred years old and never published before

DETAILS

Browse All Cornell University Press Books

Poultry diseases, causes, symptoms and treatment, with notes on post-mortem examinations

DETAILS

Browse All Cornell University Press Books

History and Power in the Study of Law

DETAILS ~ READ

Browse All Cornell University Press Books

Images from the Region of the Pueblo Indians of North America

DETAILS ~ READ

Browse All Cornell University Press Books

Women's Work and Chicano Families

DETAILS ~ READ

Browse All Cornell University Press Books

The Democracy Development Machine

DETAILS ~ READ

Browse All Cornell University Press Books